The biggest national publicity the Appalachian Trail has had in recent years was when the bad-boy governor of South Carolina, Mark Sanford, lied to his wife and the media (what? A politician lied?) about his dalliance with his girlfriend, covering up his sneaking out by saying he'd been hiking on the Appalachian Trail.
Well, if governors ever do actually try carrying their weight on that trail, let's just hope the governor of New Jersey, Chris Christie, doesn't try it. Christie, as you may know, is the governor who was recently flown to his son's high-school baseball game in a helicopter, at taxpayer's expense, and after landing got into a car to be driven the last 100 yards to the field. Oh, America, how roly-poly we have become. John F. Kennedy, who lamented our unfitness in a landmark essay titled "The Soft American," must be rolling in his grave.
But I digress.
For me, the Appalachian Trail (or the "A.T.", as we call it) has a very different meaning than it does for all the late-night comedians and commentators who riffed on the South Carolina lie. The A.T. is not only the longest and one of the most beautiful hiking trails in America; it is also one of the greatest places in the country to go for a long run.
A segment of the A.T. also happens to be the most challenging segment of America's largest and oldest ultramarathon, the JFK 50-mile. Entries for this year's JFK (which takes place November 19) opened on July 1. The race could well be filled by the end of this week. And if you are one of those who get in and can look forward to that run five months from now, it's time to begin thinking about a subject that will loom quite large on that day--running on rocks.
I remember doing a practice run on the A.T. section of that storied course around 36 years ago, in preparation for my first JFK. The course follows the A.T. from around the 3-mile point at the South Mountain trailhead to around 16 miles at the foot of Weverton Cliffs, where the trail drops precipitously to the Potomac River. Most of the trail is very nice for running, but a few sections are wickedly rocky. Somewhere around the 14-mile point, on that day so long ago, my left toe caught a rock and I did a hard face-plant. I got up slowly, stunned and bleeding, and told myself, "I sure better remember this spot when I run the race!"
And remember it I did. Over the years, remembered it again and again, because along that stretch I kept falling again and again. Couldn't I learn? By now I've run the JFK 15 times, I think, and I've done face-plants either approaching the Weverton Cliffs descent or on the boulder-strewn descent itself, at least six of those times. The falls are uncannily similar: I'm focusing hard, trying to watch where I put my feet, but also trying to move fast. The problem is that it's November, and this is deciduous forest where most of the leaves are now on the ground. The leaf cover is thick enough to cover a lot of the rocks, and while I'm usually pretty adept at trail running, I also have an unconscious, long-ingrained habit of running over logs and rocks the way a sprinter runs over hurdles--clearing as closely as possible for maximum speed. Evidently, sooner or later, I come to a spot where the optical center of my brain registers an approaching leaf-covered bump and subconsciously estimates that this bump is, let's say, a 2-inch leaf-cover over a 7-inch-high rock. The brain sends the leg an instruction to lift the bottom of the shoe 8 inches so as to brush through the top of the leaves while leaving an inch of clearance over the rock--only it turns out to be actually a 1-inch leaf cover over an 8-inch rock. That still might be OK, except that I've been running for over two and a quarter hours now, over some fairly rough terrain, and my legs are a little tired, and while the leg whose turn it is thinks it is lifting 8 inches, it's only reaching seven and three-fourths.
The other thing I should mention is that this section must be where the ancient Short Hill-South Mountain Fault once caused one mother of a rumble, wreaking rockular havoc with the earth. Since then, the Appalachian Mountains have lain stunned, watching silently for any overzealous humans they might ambush and maketh to lie down with them in mutual contemplation of what it means to grow ever older. Compared with the Rockies or Himalayas, the Appalachians are very, very old. So, for the past eight or nine hundred million years, more or less, this rugged ridge has been shrinking and compacting. The rocks have become solidly embedded. There are no loose rocks on the A.T. If you kick a loose rock on the Pacific Crest Trail in California, you might start a landslide. If you kick one on the Appalachian Trail, it isn't going anywhere. My toe caught that one-fourth inch of miscalculated rock, which may have been a rogue outcrop of Mesoproterozoic granite or may have been something a few hundred million years younger, but I really didn't have time to ask. With the my left foot brought to an absolute halt, the rest of me flew forward and down.
Six times this has happened over the years, and five of those times the response built into my wiring has been the same: My arms, elbows, and knees fly forward to break the fall and protect the face. The next runner behind me stops and asks, "Are you OK?" I reply, "I'm OK." I don't really know if I am, but can't bear the thought of being out of the race. I get up, blood streaming down my legs and arms, and continue running--very slowly--down the trail,.
The sixth time was last year. I was a year older (69) and maybe a tad weaker. This time, my knees, elbows, and hands all flew forward as usual, but my head hit the ground nonetheless. Crack--forehead on a rock. "Are you OK?" said a runner. "I'm OK," I said. There were 36 miles to go, and I needed to get back in the race. That's me, about a mile later, in the photo above.
This old-dogs-don't-learn experience of mine raises a question that a lot of JFK entrants (those who have run this before, as well as newbies) may be asking now:
How do you run this course?
Well, from an old guy who seems to be getting more confused as the years go by, here's a not-so-simple answer. The best strategy for running the JFK is to follow all of the following three rules, and I don't mean to be facetious.
1. Run the A.T. section fairly slowly and cautiously, so you get to Weverton without undue bleeding and can then run fast and carefree the rest of the way.
2. Go for broke, run the A.T. as fast as you can, feet flying high to clear the rocks, because if you do this and get away with it, you'll reach the easy part of the course (C&O Canal Towpath) with a big lead on your competition and will be able to basically coast the rest of the way.
3. Most of all, go into this race having practiced running over rocks as often as possible all summer, and having coached your brain to please add another half-inch to the clearance instructions it sends to the legs. Then, on race day, don't run with a conscious strategy at all--run to be a happy part of that wild and beautiful course all the way, at whatever speeds your trained instincts tell you. Don't force it, don't fear it. The Appalachian Trail is home. So is the Potomac River towpath that follows; and so is the wending country road that will take you over the final miles.
Next post: Final selection of "The 10 Most Iconic Running Events in America," to be posted in about a week.
Josh about to pass his grandpa
Here, at age three, Josh regularly runs a mile or two with me--and I have to work hard to keep up!
Wednesday, July 6, 2011
Sunday, June 26, 2011
The Most Iconic American Running Events: Your Nominations, Please!
In a couple of weeks, I'd like to publish a list of the "10 Most Iconic Running Events in America." I started musing about this a few days ago while planning my racing schedule for the remainder of 2011, and realizing that although the JFK 50-mile isn't until November, the entry deadline is already upon us. Entries open July 1 for runners who meet the "A" qualification standard (see jfk50mile.org for details), and there's a good chance the race will be filled by July 2. If there are still places available in the thousand-runner field after a week, runners meeting the "B" standard can enter. There are way more people who want to run this race than can be accommodated on the Appalachian Trail.
This will be JFK's 49th year, which makes it the oldest continuously-run ultra in America. It's also the largest ultra, and one of the most competitive. (The Western States 100-Mile is widely considered the most competitive ultra, and I won't argue with that, but JFK is no slouch--consider that when seven-time Western States champion Scott Jurek came to the JFK two years ago, he finished 11th, and when Michael Wardian came to JFK after finishing third in the World 50k championship in Gibraltar, last year, he placed 6th.) However you measure it, JFK is an iconic phenomenon.
But of course, there are other iconic races as well. The Boston Marathon, I'd say, is in a class by itself. When I was a young runner in the 1950s and '60s, the dream of every long-distance runner was to someday run Boston. In my own fantasies, Boston was right up there with the Olympics. And indeed, to this day, faster times have been run at Boston than in any Olympic Marathon in history.
While Boston and the JFK 50 are the two most iconic long-distance races I have ever had the thrill of running, I know perfectly well that for other runners, there are many other events that have had that kind of aura. Western States, of course. There are thousands of annual events out there now, but I want to make a short list of the most iconic ones. It won't be scientific or unbiased (neither is American Idol or the U.S. presidential election), but it will be fun. There's no way to objectively define "iconic," but here are a few suggested attributes:
Longevity: a race that's been around since before man walked on the moon, or at least since before "Chariots of Fire" was produced.
Popularity: hordes of people want to get into it, so it fills up months before the event.
Competitiveness: Elite runners are drawn to it. The front-runners in this event can outrun antelopes!
A uniquely spectacular or challenging course: awesome elevation profile, amazing views, or a million live spectators.
"Dream" quotient: It's an event you dream of going to someday--a race you want to be able to tell your grandkids you ran. If you're getting along in your years, like me, it's on your Bucket List.
Out of the innumerable candidates, what would be examples of events that meet some of those criteria? In addition to Boston and JFK, some events that leap to mind (in roughly ascending order of race distance) include the Penn Relays, Prefontaine Classic, Peachtree Road Race, Falmouth Road Race, Dipsea, Bay to Breakers, Gasparilla Classic, Cherry Blossom 10-mile, New York Marathon, Way too Cool 50k, Western States 100, and Badwater 136.
But that's just what leaps to mind for me. What about you? Write your nominations below (click on "comments"), or send me an e-mail me at edayresrun@gmail.com. Pick one or pick ten, whatever you like. Give reasons! In a couple of weeks, based on your comments and on my own 54 years of running adventures, I'll post the results. Looking forward to hearing from you!
This will be JFK's 49th year, which makes it the oldest continuously-run ultra in America. It's also the largest ultra, and one of the most competitive. (The Western States 100-Mile is widely considered the most competitive ultra, and I won't argue with that, but JFK is no slouch--consider that when seven-time Western States champion Scott Jurek came to the JFK two years ago, he finished 11th, and when Michael Wardian came to JFK after finishing third in the World 50k championship in Gibraltar, last year, he placed 6th.) However you measure it, JFK is an iconic phenomenon.
But of course, there are other iconic races as well. The Boston Marathon, I'd say, is in a class by itself. When I was a young runner in the 1950s and '60s, the dream of every long-distance runner was to someday run Boston. In my own fantasies, Boston was right up there with the Olympics. And indeed, to this day, faster times have been run at Boston than in any Olympic Marathon in history.
While Boston and the JFK 50 are the two most iconic long-distance races I have ever had the thrill of running, I know perfectly well that for other runners, there are many other events that have had that kind of aura. Western States, of course. There are thousands of annual events out there now, but I want to make a short list of the most iconic ones. It won't be scientific or unbiased (neither is American Idol or the U.S. presidential election), but it will be fun. There's no way to objectively define "iconic," but here are a few suggested attributes:
Longevity: a race that's been around since before man walked on the moon, or at least since before "Chariots of Fire" was produced.
Popularity: hordes of people want to get into it, so it fills up months before the event.
Competitiveness: Elite runners are drawn to it. The front-runners in this event can outrun antelopes!
A uniquely spectacular or challenging course: awesome elevation profile, amazing views, or a million live spectators.
"Dream" quotient: It's an event you dream of going to someday--a race you want to be able to tell your grandkids you ran. If you're getting along in your years, like me, it's on your Bucket List.
Out of the innumerable candidates, what would be examples of events that meet some of those criteria? In addition to Boston and JFK, some events that leap to mind (in roughly ascending order of race distance) include the Penn Relays, Prefontaine Classic, Peachtree Road Race, Falmouth Road Race, Dipsea, Bay to Breakers, Gasparilla Classic, Cherry Blossom 10-mile, New York Marathon, Way too Cool 50k, Western States 100, and Badwater 136.
But that's just what leaps to mind for me. What about you? Write your nominations below (click on "comments"), or send me an e-mail me at edayresrun@gmail.com. Pick one or pick ten, whatever you like. Give reasons! In a couple of weeks, based on your comments and on my own 54 years of running adventures, I'll post the results. Looking forward to hearing from you!
Sunday, June 19, 2011
Junk Food, Endurance, and Longevity
I remember reading, several decades ago, that Bill Rodgers had a huge weakness for mayonaise. That didn't stop him from winning the New York Marathon four times and the Boston Marathon four times.
I also remember learning (first-hand) that the notorious "black-socks Brits" of working-class England would go out after a hard day's work in the factories and run brutal workouts, then retire to the pub to quaff prodigious amounts of beer that was almost as black as their socks. The heavy drinking didn't stop them from achieving great performances in ultras, including a world record for the 100-mile run.
I don't know how many times I've stopped at an aid station and found on the table, along with the usual bananas and electrolyte drinks, an assortment of candy, white-flour pretzels, potato chips, or peanut-butter-and-jelly sandwiches on white bread. That hasn't stopped the population of runners finishing long-distance races from expanding as fast as the bellies of the non-running population are expanding. And the runners, of course, look pretty fit.
And finally, I don't know how many times I've read or heard about runners gorging happily on pizza. Pizza isn't a bad food if it's made with whole-grain crust and olive oil (no transfat in the crust) and a tomato sauce that isn't saturated with sugar and salt. But the standard commercial pizza . . . uh . . . from a nutritional standpoint (content of refined carbs, salt, and fat) is about as bad as fries or potato chips. And if it has pepperoni on top, add a generous dose of nitrates, sodium, and chemicals of unknown provenance. Yet, pizza now seems to be at the center of post-run camaraderie and celebration of life.
What I'm inching toward saying here is that while running and other endurance activities (bicycling, hiking, mountain climbing) have fostered a great awakening about health and vitality for millions of people, a lot of runners may still be half-asleep about the connection between long-term fitness and nutrtion. The short-term connection is well understood: If you're a serious runner, you burn a lot of calories and you get lean and enduring. And so strong is that connection that in the short term it almost doesn't matter what you eat: an 8-mile run burns off a thousand calories and gives you the freedom to enjoy a rich dessert without regret.
What's less well understood, however, is the long-term connection. If you are 30 years old today, and hope to continue running and aren't in danger of gaining weight, does the food you eat have any impact on how healthy or fit you'll be a decade or two from now--or how well you'll be able to run then? Nutritional and medical research has very little to tell us about that, because the industries that fund research have no real interest in finding out. But another reason so little is known about long-term impacts (on human performance, as well as on health) is that our culture has made us more and more oblivious to long-range consequences of anything at all, whether it be carbon dioxide emissions, deforestation, or human population growth. It's a familiar observation that our attention spans have gotten shorter. So have our outlooks on the future.
The tendency of most Americans is to feel that if what you eat today doesn't hurt your performance tomorrow or next week, there's nothing to be concerned about. I don't share that feeling. In 1954, when I was 13 years old, my father--who had struggled with respiratory disease all his life and was in danger of dying from emphysema--met a radical doctor who told him that if he wanted to live, he'd have to do three things: (1) stop eating all highly refined carbohydrates (white sugar, white flour, white rice, soft drinks, etc.); (2) cut out all hydrogenated fats (lard, Crisco, margarine, etc.); and (3) eat lots of raw, fresh vegetables and fruits. My father made the change, recovered from the illness, and lived another 40 years. But I, too, decided to make that change. I didn't have any respiratory problems, but I did have a radical thought of my own: If a natural-foods diet could help make a sick person well, wouldn't it also make a well person more well?
As it happened, that was also around the time I was developing an interest in running. That year, Roger Bannister ran the first 4-minute mile, and it made huge headlines around the world--and had a big impact on my adolescent aspirations. The year after that, I began running with my high-school cross-country team. I never dreamed, then, that I would still be running as a middle-aged man decades later, but I did think from the outset that the diet that was helping my dad could also help my running over the long term. I suppose "long term" for me then meant eight years of high-school and college, because in the 1950s, most runners were finished after their last college track meet at age 21. Later, I'd discover that organized running could continue for adults. When I went to my first road races after college, in the 1960s, I was fascinated to see that some of the runners were as old as 30 or 35, and one or two were actually in their early 40s!
Over the years, enormous demographic changes came to long-distance running. In 1968, Kathrine Switzer became the Rosa Parks of marathon running, breaking the ban against women at Boston. Two decades later, the Bay-to-Breakers 8-miler in San Francisco would attract 100,000 runners of whom about 40,000 were women. And as the gender balance of running shifted, so did the age balance. I haven't seen recent stats (does anyone out there know?) but my impression is that now the median age of road and trail runners is around 40. In the mean time, I have somehow gotten to be 69. And I'm far from the oldest runner out there; I'll turn 70 in October, and at the JFK 50-mile I'll have lots of competition in the 70-79 division.
Oh boy, I'm as slow to get to the point in my writing as I am getting to the finish line in an ultra. (Don't look for me on Twitter!) The point here is that as the decades have gone by, the long-term benefits of good nutrition have become more and more apparent to me. It's been gradual, and subtle--but unmistakeable. Eating organic kale and tofu the night before a race doesn't give me super powers in the next day's run, the way Popeye suddenly got his huge biceps after eating spinach in the cartoons of the 1950s (remember those, fellow sexagenarians?). What it does do is keep me feeling very much as alive and fit today as I felt at 20 or 30 or 40.
I suspect that today's 20-year-old or 30-year-old doesn't really worry much about what life will be like for him or her at age 70. By then, who knows what climate change, or post-peak-oil economic chaos, or the growth of human population to a projected 11 billion (it was about 2 billion when I was born) will have done to our planet and our health. Who knows whether there will even be any organized running then. Will there be affordable fuel to drive to races? Will the forests be closed, or razed? Will we be focused on coping with pandemics, or civil disorder?
I can empathize with the tendency to dwell on living for the moment--enjoying life now, this year, because next year is beyond imagining. But I do have this one thought to share: How we deal with long-run health and fitness as individuals is closely linked to how successfully we manage the long-run prospects of our civilization. And I use that term "long run" advisedly. In a forthcoming post, I'll share the results of an investigation I did on a specific junk food (I'll name the product), and its potential, long-run impacts.
I also remember learning (first-hand) that the notorious "black-socks Brits" of working-class England would go out after a hard day's work in the factories and run brutal workouts, then retire to the pub to quaff prodigious amounts of beer that was almost as black as their socks. The heavy drinking didn't stop them from achieving great performances in ultras, including a world record for the 100-mile run.
I don't know how many times I've stopped at an aid station and found on the table, along with the usual bananas and electrolyte drinks, an assortment of candy, white-flour pretzels, potato chips, or peanut-butter-and-jelly sandwiches on white bread. That hasn't stopped the population of runners finishing long-distance races from expanding as fast as the bellies of the non-running population are expanding. And the runners, of course, look pretty fit.
And finally, I don't know how many times I've read or heard about runners gorging happily on pizza. Pizza isn't a bad food if it's made with whole-grain crust and olive oil (no transfat in the crust) and a tomato sauce that isn't saturated with sugar and salt. But the standard commercial pizza . . . uh . . . from a nutritional standpoint (content of refined carbs, salt, and fat) is about as bad as fries or potato chips. And if it has pepperoni on top, add a generous dose of nitrates, sodium, and chemicals of unknown provenance. Yet, pizza now seems to be at the center of post-run camaraderie and celebration of life.
What I'm inching toward saying here is that while running and other endurance activities (bicycling, hiking, mountain climbing) have fostered a great awakening about health and vitality for millions of people, a lot of runners may still be half-asleep about the connection between long-term fitness and nutrtion. The short-term connection is well understood: If you're a serious runner, you burn a lot of calories and you get lean and enduring. And so strong is that connection that in the short term it almost doesn't matter what you eat: an 8-mile run burns off a thousand calories and gives you the freedom to enjoy a rich dessert without regret.
What's less well understood, however, is the long-term connection. If you are 30 years old today, and hope to continue running and aren't in danger of gaining weight, does the food you eat have any impact on how healthy or fit you'll be a decade or two from now--or how well you'll be able to run then? Nutritional and medical research has very little to tell us about that, because the industries that fund research have no real interest in finding out. But another reason so little is known about long-term impacts (on human performance, as well as on health) is that our culture has made us more and more oblivious to long-range consequences of anything at all, whether it be carbon dioxide emissions, deforestation, or human population growth. It's a familiar observation that our attention spans have gotten shorter. So have our outlooks on the future.
The tendency of most Americans is to feel that if what you eat today doesn't hurt your performance tomorrow or next week, there's nothing to be concerned about. I don't share that feeling. In 1954, when I was 13 years old, my father--who had struggled with respiratory disease all his life and was in danger of dying from emphysema--met a radical doctor who told him that if he wanted to live, he'd have to do three things: (1) stop eating all highly refined carbohydrates (white sugar, white flour, white rice, soft drinks, etc.); (2) cut out all hydrogenated fats (lard, Crisco, margarine, etc.); and (3) eat lots of raw, fresh vegetables and fruits. My father made the change, recovered from the illness, and lived another 40 years. But I, too, decided to make that change. I didn't have any respiratory problems, but I did have a radical thought of my own: If a natural-foods diet could help make a sick person well, wouldn't it also make a well person more well?
As it happened, that was also around the time I was developing an interest in running. That year, Roger Bannister ran the first 4-minute mile, and it made huge headlines around the world--and had a big impact on my adolescent aspirations. The year after that, I began running with my high-school cross-country team. I never dreamed, then, that I would still be running as a middle-aged man decades later, but I did think from the outset that the diet that was helping my dad could also help my running over the long term. I suppose "long term" for me then meant eight years of high-school and college, because in the 1950s, most runners were finished after their last college track meet at age 21. Later, I'd discover that organized running could continue for adults. When I went to my first road races after college, in the 1960s, I was fascinated to see that some of the runners were as old as 30 or 35, and one or two were actually in their early 40s!
Over the years, enormous demographic changes came to long-distance running. In 1968, Kathrine Switzer became the Rosa Parks of marathon running, breaking the ban against women at Boston. Two decades later, the Bay-to-Breakers 8-miler in San Francisco would attract 100,000 runners of whom about 40,000 were women. And as the gender balance of running shifted, so did the age balance. I haven't seen recent stats (does anyone out there know?) but my impression is that now the median age of road and trail runners is around 40. In the mean time, I have somehow gotten to be 69. And I'm far from the oldest runner out there; I'll turn 70 in October, and at the JFK 50-mile I'll have lots of competition in the 70-79 division.
Oh boy, I'm as slow to get to the point in my writing as I am getting to the finish line in an ultra. (Don't look for me on Twitter!) The point here is that as the decades have gone by, the long-term benefits of good nutrition have become more and more apparent to me. It's been gradual, and subtle--but unmistakeable. Eating organic kale and tofu the night before a race doesn't give me super powers in the next day's run, the way Popeye suddenly got his huge biceps after eating spinach in the cartoons of the 1950s (remember those, fellow sexagenarians?). What it does do is keep me feeling very much as alive and fit today as I felt at 20 or 30 or 40.
I suspect that today's 20-year-old or 30-year-old doesn't really worry much about what life will be like for him or her at age 70. By then, who knows what climate change, or post-peak-oil economic chaos, or the growth of human population to a projected 11 billion (it was about 2 billion when I was born) will have done to our planet and our health. Who knows whether there will even be any organized running then. Will there be affordable fuel to drive to races? Will the forests be closed, or razed? Will we be focused on coping with pandemics, or civil disorder?
I can empathize with the tendency to dwell on living for the moment--enjoying life now, this year, because next year is beyond imagining. But I do have this one thought to share: How we deal with long-run health and fitness as individuals is closely linked to how successfully we manage the long-run prospects of our civilization. And I use that term "long run" advisedly. In a forthcoming post, I'll share the results of an investigation I did on a specific junk food (I'll name the product), and its potential, long-run impacts.
Friday, June 3, 2011
"Born to Run" -- a Tough-Love Review
You've probably either read Christopher McDougall's book Born to Run: A Hidden Tribe, Superathletes, and the Greatest Race the World Has Never Seen, or at least heard about it. It has had a big influence on the way many runners run, and it also seems to have caused passionate reactions: some runners say the story it tells has rescued them from injury and given them a new sense of freedom. Others consider the book misguided.
My own view is that this book is actually made up of three very different stories glommed together into one: a wild, over-the-top, tall tale about the legendary barefoot-running Tarahumara Indians of Mexico's remote Copper Canyons; a surprisingly bitter polemic about modern running shoes; and a fascinating perspective on human evolution. The first two stories are somewhat misguided and misinformed, though entertaining. The third is well researched and, I think, profoundly important.
I don't know if I have ever before read a book that is so wrong and so right between the same two covers. So, this review can't be like one of those "thumbs up" or "thumbs down" assessments we've come to expect in our ever more polarized, quick-message pop culture. For one thing, it would be a mistake to count my two basically "down" assessments versus one "up" as indicating a net-negative. The third story--about our origins and nature as humans--outweighs the other two.
Here are my thoughts about those three strange-bedfellow stories, in turn:
The Over-the-Top Tall Tale: On the second page, McDougall writes: "When it comes to ultradistances, nothing can beat a Tarahumara runner--not a racehorse, not a cheetah, not an Olympic marathoner." Well, that's true about the racehorse and the cheetah, for the simple reason (discussed later in the book) that when it comes to ultradistances, nothing can beat a well trained human runner. But in this provocative sentence, McDougall seems to be singling out the Tarahumara as different from the rest of us. (To emphasize that this wasn't just a careless mistake, he repeats the point a hundred pages later: "They had proved themselves, indisputably, as the greatest ultrarunners on earth.") What's actually the case, though, as we will later see, is that the Tarahumara are not fundamentally different. As the book's title suggests, all humans are born to run. And there are equally great ultrarunners in many countries.
As for the "not an Olympic marathoner" part, that's unsubstantiated speculation, since Olympic marathoners rarely run ultradistances. Marathons and ultras are two very different things! To put that in perspective, note that of the many hundreds of thousands of runners who have competed in America's largest marathon (New York) or largest ultra (JFK 50-mile) over the past four decades, only two have ever finished in the top three places in both races.
So, in saying "nothing" can beat the Tarahumara when in comes to ultradistances, McDougall is comparing apples and oranges (cheetahs and humans, or marathoners and ultramarathoners). What he cleverly does NOT say is that when it comes to ultradistances, no other ultrarunners can beat a Tarahumara! Yes, later in the book we will read a dramatitic account of a small race in Copper Canyon where a group of Tarahumara run 50 miles with a group of gringo Americans, and one of the Tarahumara guys finishes ahead of the seven-time Western States 100-mile winner Scott Jurek. Jurek is a close second, and overall the two groups from culturally opposite ends of the earth are fairly evenly matched. And what if some of the top Russian, Japanese, or South African runners had been there too? Bottom line: humans are humans. Give McDougall credit for eventually emphasizing that critical point.
In the early going, though, the author clearly wants to lure the reader with a myth that ranks right up there with Big Foot in its breathless buzz about superhuman beings somewhere out there in the deadly Barranca del Cobres--a land of treacherous trails, rattlesnakes, killer heat, ruthless drug dealers, and mysterious murders where an epic "greatest race the world has never seen" will take place. I think the Spartathlon, or a lot of other races, have been greater.
So for the first third of the book, McDougall keeps building on these misleading comparisons, at one point gratuitously contrasting the Tarahumara scrambling up and down steep canyon trails with Lance Armstrong struggling to run on a paved road: "Lance Armstrong is one if the greatest endurance athletes of all time, and he could barely shuffle through his first marathon despite sucking down an energy gel nearly every mile." When I read that, I thought: What would happen if you took a great Tarahumara runner who'd never trained for bicycle racing, and put him in the Tour de France? Again, apples and oranges.
The wild-tale part of Born to Run isn't just deceptive myth-building, though. Some of it is an unfortunate lack of knowledge about running history. In one gee-whiz paragraph, McDougall writes, "According to the Mexican historian Francisco Almada, a Tarahumara champion once ran 435 miles, the equivalent of setting out for a jog in New York City and not stopping until you were closing in on Detroit"--as though such a feat is the stuff of legend. Maybe McDougall should have consulted a historian of running, as well. The long-distance-running historian Dan Brannen, for example, would have pointed out that the Greek runner Yiannis Kouros, among many others in many countries, has run more than twice that distance nonstop. In 19th-century England, runners exceeded that distance in regular 6-day competitions, as shown in the vintage advertisement at the top of this page. McDougall has studied the Tarahumara well, but doesn't exhibit much knowledge of ultrarunning in the rest of the world.
The Polemic About Running Shoes: I discussed this in my last blog post, noting that here, too, McDougall is just plain wrong about some of this facts. When I read his account of Nike co-founder Bill Bowerman, I was actually a bit saddened. McDougall writes that Bowerman invented the modern running shoe in 1972 by sticking a chunk of rubber under the heel to enable a runner to land on his heel and thereby unnaturally lengthen his stride. Ostensibly, that invited injury. Implicitly, it seemed, McDougall was blaming his own struggle with a painful foot injury on a guy who died years ago and who, if he'd ever been confronted by his accuser, would have pointed out that while he did indeed invent the waffle sole, he didn't invent the built-up rubber heel. That had been invented over half a century earlier. Claiming that Bowerman thought up the built-up heel caught my attention not only because I had been running with built-up rubber heels for years before Bowerman's presumed invention, but also because of a memorable incident in my first marathon, when I found myself pulling even with Ted Corbitt, whom the New York Times called the "godfather of American ultrarunning." At the time, I was "running on my toes," as my high school coach had taught, but Corbitt glanced at my footfall and suggested that I might run better if I let myself touch down on my heels. This was years before the first Nikes, and runners who wanted built-up heel cushioning could easily get it in shoes made by Adidas or Tiger. (In fact, I've been told by a knowledgeable friend that the first Nikes were basically Tiger or Asics models with a Nike swoosh glued on.) And the heel-running Ted Corbitt's multi-day and 50-mile performances are just as impressive, even today, as the Tarahumara's. Moreover, it wasn't just in the mid-1960s that some of our shoes had built-up heel rubber. In my collection of old running memorabilia, I have a hundred-year-old advertisement from a company called O'Sullivan Heels of Live Rubber, featuring a photo of the Olympic marathon champion of 1908, Johnny Hayes, shaking hands with the company's owner, Humphrey O'Sullivan. In the caption, Hayes is quoted as informing Sullivan that the shoes with which he had won the Olympic Marathon had the O'Sullivan Heels of Live Rubber, and that "I always wear your heels in my races."
What, then, of McDougall's core argument that running injuries have proliferated since 1972? I strongly suspect that here, McDougall has fallen into the very common trap of confusing correlation with causation. The fact that the rise of Nikes and other modern running shoes is correlated with a proliferation of running injuries does not mean they are the cause. The building of the modern Interstate Highways in America was correlated with a rise in the number of motor vehicle collisions and fatalities, but it wasn't the cause! Auto deaths increased despite the improved safety of the highways--because of other factors such as the rise of rush-hour congestion, happy-hour drinking, road rage, and the thrall of cars among teens (I was there). Similarly, I think, running injuries increased after the early 1970s because far more people were doing things like trying to complete a marathon in their first year of running. In the 1950s and '60s, most long-distance runners trained for years before attempting a marathon, so they were less vulnerable to injuries caused by ramping up too fast.
Finally, just one more point of misconstrued history. McDougall compares Bowerman with the legendary coach Arthur Lydiard, writing: "Lydiard was by far the superior track mind; he'd coached many more Olympic champions and world-record holders. . . . Lydiard liked Bowerman and respected him as a coach, but Good God! What was this junk he was selling?"
Is that what Lydiard thought? Well, in 1977, I filmed an interview with Lydiard at my house in Virginia, and got to know something about what he thought. And as it happens, Lydiard, too, designed and sold running shoes--under the Lydiard name. They were the same kind of basic design as the new Nikes. The "junk" argument is apparently McDougall's guess at what Lydiard was thinking, not anything Lydiard said. Bottom line: cultural evolution has put a lot of distance between us modern runners and our barefoot ancestors--and while some of us are still able to run like the hominids, others are not. Nike's shoes (like Lydiard's or earlier Adidas or Asics models) were a boon to some of us, and too much cushioned protection for others, but there's very little evidence that they caused an epidemic of injuries. The epidemic was probably caused by too many people trying to ramp up their mileage and speed too fast. Americans have become more and more impatient.
A New Perspective on Human Evolution: OK, I've taken too long to get here. I talk too much. Mea culpa. This third story is what makes reading McDougall's book worthwhile. And it's a curious thing, too: in the earlier stories, McDougall does what I supppose he does for magazines like Men's Fitness or Esquire--he indulges in a lot of macho, gonzo-journalist exclamations like "First, two villages would get together and spend the night making bets and pounding tesjuino, a homemade beer that could blister paint." Or, "Secret agents, whizzing bullets, prehistoric kingdoms . . . even Ernest Hemingway would have shut up and surrendered the floor if Fisher walked into the bar." When he gets to the science, though, McDougall drops the slick language and tells a story that is--to my mind--far more exciting and insightful than any of the wild or polemicized stuff that precedes it.
The gist of this story is that for a long time, evolutionary scientists have believed we humans evolved as walkers, but in recent years a few bold researchers have put together a now convincing case, the Running Man theory, that we evolved as long-distance runners who hunted by chasing down faster-running animals by getting them overheated or wearing them out. Key players in this scientific saga were researchers David Carrier and Dennis Bramble of the University of Utah, Daniel Lieberman of Harvard, and Louis Liebenberg of Noordhoek, South Africa. McDougall does an excellent job of reconstructing the story of how these scientists built their case, drawing on both lab studies and field observations over three decades. I won't steal McDougall's thunder by attempting to summarize that story. But it's a good one, and it has profound implications not only about our past and present nature as humans, but our now endangered future, as I'll be exploring in my own writing and website.
For more discussion of our nature and future as the planet's most enduring species, see http://www.willhumansendure.com/.
My own view is that this book is actually made up of three very different stories glommed together into one: a wild, over-the-top, tall tale about the legendary barefoot-running Tarahumara Indians of Mexico's remote Copper Canyons; a surprisingly bitter polemic about modern running shoes; and a fascinating perspective on human evolution. The first two stories are somewhat misguided and misinformed, though entertaining. The third is well researched and, I think, profoundly important.
I don't know if I have ever before read a book that is so wrong and so right between the same two covers. So, this review can't be like one of those "thumbs up" or "thumbs down" assessments we've come to expect in our ever more polarized, quick-message pop culture. For one thing, it would be a mistake to count my two basically "down" assessments versus one "up" as indicating a net-negative. The third story--about our origins and nature as humans--outweighs the other two.
Here are my thoughts about those three strange-bedfellow stories, in turn:
The Over-the-Top Tall Tale: On the second page, McDougall writes: "When it comes to ultradistances, nothing can beat a Tarahumara runner--not a racehorse, not a cheetah, not an Olympic marathoner." Well, that's true about the racehorse and the cheetah, for the simple reason (discussed later in the book) that when it comes to ultradistances, nothing can beat a well trained human runner. But in this provocative sentence, McDougall seems to be singling out the Tarahumara as different from the rest of us. (To emphasize that this wasn't just a careless mistake, he repeats the point a hundred pages later: "They had proved themselves, indisputably, as the greatest ultrarunners on earth.") What's actually the case, though, as we will later see, is that the Tarahumara are not fundamentally different. As the book's title suggests, all humans are born to run. And there are equally great ultrarunners in many countries.
As for the "not an Olympic marathoner" part, that's unsubstantiated speculation, since Olympic marathoners rarely run ultradistances. Marathons and ultras are two very different things! To put that in perspective, note that of the many hundreds of thousands of runners who have competed in America's largest marathon (New York) or largest ultra (JFK 50-mile) over the past four decades, only two have ever finished in the top three places in both races.
So, in saying "nothing" can beat the Tarahumara when in comes to ultradistances, McDougall is comparing apples and oranges (cheetahs and humans, or marathoners and ultramarathoners). What he cleverly does NOT say is that when it comes to ultradistances, no other ultrarunners can beat a Tarahumara! Yes, later in the book we will read a dramatitic account of a small race in Copper Canyon where a group of Tarahumara run 50 miles with a group of gringo Americans, and one of the Tarahumara guys finishes ahead of the seven-time Western States 100-mile winner Scott Jurek. Jurek is a close second, and overall the two groups from culturally opposite ends of the earth are fairly evenly matched. And what if some of the top Russian, Japanese, or South African runners had been there too? Bottom line: humans are humans. Give McDougall credit for eventually emphasizing that critical point.
In the early going, though, the author clearly wants to lure the reader with a myth that ranks right up there with Big Foot in its breathless buzz about superhuman beings somewhere out there in the deadly Barranca del Cobres--a land of treacherous trails, rattlesnakes, killer heat, ruthless drug dealers, and mysterious murders where an epic "greatest race the world has never seen" will take place. I think the Spartathlon, or a lot of other races, have been greater.
So for the first third of the book, McDougall keeps building on these misleading comparisons, at one point gratuitously contrasting the Tarahumara scrambling up and down steep canyon trails with Lance Armstrong struggling to run on a paved road: "Lance Armstrong is one if the greatest endurance athletes of all time, and he could barely shuffle through his first marathon despite sucking down an energy gel nearly every mile." When I read that, I thought: What would happen if you took a great Tarahumara runner who'd never trained for bicycle racing, and put him in the Tour de France? Again, apples and oranges.
The wild-tale part of Born to Run isn't just deceptive myth-building, though. Some of it is an unfortunate lack of knowledge about running history. In one gee-whiz paragraph, McDougall writes, "According to the Mexican historian Francisco Almada, a Tarahumara champion once ran 435 miles, the equivalent of setting out for a jog in New York City and not stopping until you were closing in on Detroit"--as though such a feat is the stuff of legend. Maybe McDougall should have consulted a historian of running, as well. The long-distance-running historian Dan Brannen, for example, would have pointed out that the Greek runner Yiannis Kouros, among many others in many countries, has run more than twice that distance nonstop. In 19th-century England, runners exceeded that distance in regular 6-day competitions, as shown in the vintage advertisement at the top of this page. McDougall has studied the Tarahumara well, but doesn't exhibit much knowledge of ultrarunning in the rest of the world.
The Polemic About Running Shoes: I discussed this in my last blog post, noting that here, too, McDougall is just plain wrong about some of this facts. When I read his account of Nike co-founder Bill Bowerman, I was actually a bit saddened. McDougall writes that Bowerman invented the modern running shoe in 1972 by sticking a chunk of rubber under the heel to enable a runner to land on his heel and thereby unnaturally lengthen his stride. Ostensibly, that invited injury. Implicitly, it seemed, McDougall was blaming his own struggle with a painful foot injury on a guy who died years ago and who, if he'd ever been confronted by his accuser, would have pointed out that while he did indeed invent the waffle sole, he didn't invent the built-up rubber heel. That had been invented over half a century earlier. Claiming that Bowerman thought up the built-up heel caught my attention not only because I had been running with built-up rubber heels for years before Bowerman's presumed invention, but also because of a memorable incident in my first marathon, when I found myself pulling even with Ted Corbitt, whom the New York Times called the "godfather of American ultrarunning." At the time, I was "running on my toes," as my high school coach had taught, but Corbitt glanced at my footfall and suggested that I might run better if I let myself touch down on my heels. This was years before the first Nikes, and runners who wanted built-up heel cushioning could easily get it in shoes made by Adidas or Tiger. (In fact, I've been told by a knowledgeable friend that the first Nikes were basically Tiger or Asics models with a Nike swoosh glued on.) And the heel-running Ted Corbitt's multi-day and 50-mile performances are just as impressive, even today, as the Tarahumara's. Moreover, it wasn't just in the mid-1960s that some of our shoes had built-up heel rubber. In my collection of old running memorabilia, I have a hundred-year-old advertisement from a company called O'Sullivan Heels of Live Rubber, featuring a photo of the Olympic marathon champion of 1908, Johnny Hayes, shaking hands with the company's owner, Humphrey O'Sullivan. In the caption, Hayes is quoted as informing Sullivan that the shoes with which he had won the Olympic Marathon had the O'Sullivan Heels of Live Rubber, and that "I always wear your heels in my races."
What, then, of McDougall's core argument that running injuries have proliferated since 1972? I strongly suspect that here, McDougall has fallen into the very common trap of confusing correlation with causation. The fact that the rise of Nikes and other modern running shoes is correlated with a proliferation of running injuries does not mean they are the cause. The building of the modern Interstate Highways in America was correlated with a rise in the number of motor vehicle collisions and fatalities, but it wasn't the cause! Auto deaths increased despite the improved safety of the highways--because of other factors such as the rise of rush-hour congestion, happy-hour drinking, road rage, and the thrall of cars among teens (I was there). Similarly, I think, running injuries increased after the early 1970s because far more people were doing things like trying to complete a marathon in their first year of running. In the 1950s and '60s, most long-distance runners trained for years before attempting a marathon, so they were less vulnerable to injuries caused by ramping up too fast.
Finally, just one more point of misconstrued history. McDougall compares Bowerman with the legendary coach Arthur Lydiard, writing: "Lydiard was by far the superior track mind; he'd coached many more Olympic champions and world-record holders. . . . Lydiard liked Bowerman and respected him as a coach, but Good God! What was this junk he was selling?"
Is that what Lydiard thought? Well, in 1977, I filmed an interview with Lydiard at my house in Virginia, and got to know something about what he thought. And as it happens, Lydiard, too, designed and sold running shoes--under the Lydiard name. They were the same kind of basic design as the new Nikes. The "junk" argument is apparently McDougall's guess at what Lydiard was thinking, not anything Lydiard said. Bottom line: cultural evolution has put a lot of distance between us modern runners and our barefoot ancestors--and while some of us are still able to run like the hominids, others are not. Nike's shoes (like Lydiard's or earlier Adidas or Asics models) were a boon to some of us, and too much cushioned protection for others, but there's very little evidence that they caused an epidemic of injuries. The epidemic was probably caused by too many people trying to ramp up their mileage and speed too fast. Americans have become more and more impatient.
A New Perspective on Human Evolution: OK, I've taken too long to get here. I talk too much. Mea culpa. This third story is what makes reading McDougall's book worthwhile. And it's a curious thing, too: in the earlier stories, McDougall does what I supppose he does for magazines like Men's Fitness or Esquire--he indulges in a lot of macho, gonzo-journalist exclamations like "First, two villages would get together and spend the night making bets and pounding tesjuino, a homemade beer that could blister paint." Or, "Secret agents, whizzing bullets, prehistoric kingdoms . . . even Ernest Hemingway would have shut up and surrendered the floor if Fisher walked into the bar." When he gets to the science, though, McDougall drops the slick language and tells a story that is--to my mind--far more exciting and insightful than any of the wild or polemicized stuff that precedes it.
The gist of this story is that for a long time, evolutionary scientists have believed we humans evolved as walkers, but in recent years a few bold researchers have put together a now convincing case, the Running Man theory, that we evolved as long-distance runners who hunted by chasing down faster-running animals by getting them overheated or wearing them out. Key players in this scientific saga were researchers David Carrier and Dennis Bramble of the University of Utah, Daniel Lieberman of Harvard, and Louis Liebenberg of Noordhoek, South Africa. McDougall does an excellent job of reconstructing the story of how these scientists built their case, drawing on both lab studies and field observations over three decades. I won't steal McDougall's thunder by attempting to summarize that story. But it's a good one, and it has profound implications not only about our past and present nature as humans, but our now endangered future, as I'll be exploring in my own writing and website.
For more discussion of our nature and future as the planet's most enduring species, see http://www.willhumansendure.com/.
Wednesday, May 18, 2011
Nefarious Nike: Can Chris McDougall be Serious?
It will be interesting to see if the barefoot and "minimalist" running shoe phenomenon turns out to be a fad. My guess is that it won't, and that in some ways, for some runners, it will be a part of our running gear for the future. But not everything about this phenomenon adds up. With the aid of a half-century's hindsight, here's my belated view of where we're going with this.
I say "belated" because I see that a lot of the impetus for this phenomenon came from the huge popularity of Christopher McDougall's book Born to Run, which I admit I did not read until quite recently. McDougall recounts the story of the barefoot-running or minimalist-sandals-running Tarahumara Indians of Mexico's remote Barrancas del Cobre (Copper Canyons), and then spins off into the history of the modern running shoe. His basic messages are (1) that the Tarahumara are the greatest runners in the world by far, and (2) that the modern running shoe is a terrible thing, ignorantly designed and cynically marketed for profit at the expense of thousands of unnecessarily injured runners, including McDougall.
I'm a little embarrassed to be reacting so belatedly, because I may be the most experienced long-distance runner in America (is there anyone else out there who has run competitively for 54 consecutive years?) and my experience has incuded (1) fairly good knowledge of the Tarahumara, and (2) fairly extensive familiarity with the history of the modern running shoe. In 1977, as the founding editor of Running Times magazine, I published three articles about the Tarahumara, and in 1984 a fourth article--shortly before the first scientific articles on the "Running Man" theory of human evolution were published.. And what our articles made clear is that while the Tarahumara are indeed amazing, they are not uniquely amazing. What made them remarkable was not that their best runners were "superathletes," as suggested by the subtitle of McDougall's book, but that everyone in their society runs. We of the USA have superathletes too (as McDougall eventually acknowledges), but we also have a huge number of people who are sadly sendentary and soft.
In the way he starts his story, suggesting that there 's a kind of god-like superhuman out there in the canyons somewhere, McDougall is over the top, as I'll discuss in a forthcoming post devoted specifically to reviewing his book. (And by the way, I won't totally trash the book, because in some respects it is really good.) And as for the origins and future of the modern running shoe--well, I think McDougall is just plain wrong. At Running Times, I published numerous independent reviews (by sports podiatrists and test runners) of running shoes from all the manufacturers--Adidas, Tiger (later Asics), New Balance, Nike, Etonic, Saucony, Brooks, Lydiard, Hi-Tec, Reebok, Turntec, Puma, and a few others. Over the years, we got feedback from hundreds of experts on biomechanics, anatomy, sports inuries, etc., and I don't think they could all have been as blindered as Born to Run suggests.
McDougall writes that the modern running shoe was invented by Nike's co-founder Bill Bowerman in 1972, and that Bowerman didn't know diddly about running. Which is a little like saying Dwight Eisenhower didn't know diddly about war. His implication seems to be that until Bowerman came along, all running shoes were what we'd now call minimalist. The new "modern" shoes introduced cushioning, pronation control, and more rubber under the heel, etc. McDougall's assessment is that these new developments were big mistakes. I disagree. Minimalist-shoe or barefoot running may be great for some people, but for others those modern shoes he disparages were a godsend.
I ran in my first pair of modern running shoes before McDougall was born, and long before Nike existed, so those shoes couldn't have been invented by Nike! (The waffle sole, yes, but the enhanced cushioning and stability, no.) I had started running cross country at Westfield (New Jersey) Senior High School in 1956, and all the kids on my team were given the standard distance-running shoes of that era--low-cut, black canvas-top shoes with no cushioning and only a small, narrow outsole under the heel. They were what we'd now call minimalist. But then I heard about the new kind of running shoe that some of the top runners were wearing, that you could get from a company called Adidas. I couldn't find a store anywhere in New Jersey that sold them, but I heard that you could get them at a place called Carlson Import Shoe Co, in New York City. I caught a train to New York and found the company in a dingy, second-story walk-up in lower Manhattan. There wasn't even a sign on the street. The shoes I bought were green and white, with kangaroo-skin uppers (later made illegal), good cushioning, and nice support in the heel. They fit me like kid gloves. They were magic, and I wish I still had them. I went from 7th man on my team to 7th in the state championship.
The thing is, those Adidas shoes were a huge improvement, at least for me, over the canvas flats. Today, I see tens of thousands of runners (many of them fairly new to the sport) going in the opposite direction, swept up in the thrall of McDougall's "naked tour" and the romance of the myth of the barefoot Tarahumara, denouncing the shoes of the past four decades as rip-offs. And I wonder if the shoe manufacturers, who have responded by offering lots of new minimalist models, are being swept up a little too easily themselves.
It's going to take me a while to sort this all out (and to learn more about the "barefoot debate"), but my present inclination is to think a lot of runners may have overreacted to the romance of the Born-to-Run cult. Philosophically, I like the idea of taking a cue from our ancient ancestors. (We need to do that in a lot of ways beyond just how we decide on footwear, as I discuss on the website http://www.willhumansendure.com/.) I think the science of the Running Man theory is sound. But civilization has subjected us to 10,000 years of cultural intervention and breeding that have separated us from our origins so drastically that it's unrealistic to think we can simply throw off our shoes and run free. Some can, but a lot of us can't. If you're starting to run at age 30 or 40 and have spent three or four decades letting your feet be carried around in rigid plastic or leather coffins on smooth floors or pavement, the muscles, tendons, and bones in your feet may retain very little of the strength and resilience our ancient ancestors had--or that today's Tarahumara still have. You may be better off doing what I did when I got those green-and-white Adidas. That was 52 years ago, and I'm still running strong. I have never bothered with shoes that cost $100 or more (McDougall is more on target in suggesting that buying one of the more expensive models can be a fool's errand), and for the past few years I've been happy with fairly basic Saucony or Asics models priced around $60 to $80, which have the same basic features those magical Adidas shoes had half a century ago. I hope the shoe companies keep making shoes like that for people like me. And if Chris McDougall would like to set up another "greatest race the world has never seen" with some of the over-70-year-old Tarahumara included, those guys can run in their sandals and I'll be there in my Sauconys. And I think I'll do pretty well.
I say "belated" because I see that a lot of the impetus for this phenomenon came from the huge popularity of Christopher McDougall's book Born to Run, which I admit I did not read until quite recently. McDougall recounts the story of the barefoot-running or minimalist-sandals-running Tarahumara Indians of Mexico's remote Barrancas del Cobre (Copper Canyons), and then spins off into the history of the modern running shoe. His basic messages are (1) that the Tarahumara are the greatest runners in the world by far, and (2) that the modern running shoe is a terrible thing, ignorantly designed and cynically marketed for profit at the expense of thousands of unnecessarily injured runners, including McDougall.
I'm a little embarrassed to be reacting so belatedly, because I may be the most experienced long-distance runner in America (is there anyone else out there who has run competitively for 54 consecutive years?) and my experience has incuded (1) fairly good knowledge of the Tarahumara, and (2) fairly extensive familiarity with the history of the modern running shoe. In 1977, as the founding editor of Running Times magazine, I published three articles about the Tarahumara, and in 1984 a fourth article--shortly before the first scientific articles on the "Running Man" theory of human evolution were published.. And what our articles made clear is that while the Tarahumara are indeed amazing, they are not uniquely amazing. What made them remarkable was not that their best runners were "superathletes," as suggested by the subtitle of McDougall's book, but that everyone in their society runs. We of the USA have superathletes too (as McDougall eventually acknowledges), but we also have a huge number of people who are sadly sendentary and soft.
In the way he starts his story, suggesting that there 's a kind of god-like superhuman out there in the canyons somewhere, McDougall is over the top, as I'll discuss in a forthcoming post devoted specifically to reviewing his book. (And by the way, I won't totally trash the book, because in some respects it is really good.) And as for the origins and future of the modern running shoe--well, I think McDougall is just plain wrong. At Running Times, I published numerous independent reviews (by sports podiatrists and test runners) of running shoes from all the manufacturers--Adidas, Tiger (later Asics), New Balance, Nike, Etonic, Saucony, Brooks, Lydiard, Hi-Tec, Reebok, Turntec, Puma, and a few others. Over the years, we got feedback from hundreds of experts on biomechanics, anatomy, sports inuries, etc., and I don't think they could all have been as blindered as Born to Run suggests.
McDougall writes that the modern running shoe was invented by Nike's co-founder Bill Bowerman in 1972, and that Bowerman didn't know diddly about running. Which is a little like saying Dwight Eisenhower didn't know diddly about war. His implication seems to be that until Bowerman came along, all running shoes were what we'd now call minimalist. The new "modern" shoes introduced cushioning, pronation control, and more rubber under the heel, etc. McDougall's assessment is that these new developments were big mistakes. I disagree. Minimalist-shoe or barefoot running may be great for some people, but for others those modern shoes he disparages were a godsend.
I ran in my first pair of modern running shoes before McDougall was born, and long before Nike existed, so those shoes couldn't have been invented by Nike! (The waffle sole, yes, but the enhanced cushioning and stability, no.) I had started running cross country at Westfield (New Jersey) Senior High School in 1956, and all the kids on my team were given the standard distance-running shoes of that era--low-cut, black canvas-top shoes with no cushioning and only a small, narrow outsole under the heel. They were what we'd now call minimalist. But then I heard about the new kind of running shoe that some of the top runners were wearing, that you could get from a company called Adidas. I couldn't find a store anywhere in New Jersey that sold them, but I heard that you could get them at a place called Carlson Import Shoe Co, in New York City. I caught a train to New York and found the company in a dingy, second-story walk-up in lower Manhattan. There wasn't even a sign on the street. The shoes I bought were green and white, with kangaroo-skin uppers (later made illegal), good cushioning, and nice support in the heel. They fit me like kid gloves. They were magic, and I wish I still had them. I went from 7th man on my team to 7th in the state championship.
The thing is, those Adidas shoes were a huge improvement, at least for me, over the canvas flats. Today, I see tens of thousands of runners (many of them fairly new to the sport) going in the opposite direction, swept up in the thrall of McDougall's "naked tour" and the romance of the myth of the barefoot Tarahumara, denouncing the shoes of the past four decades as rip-offs. And I wonder if the shoe manufacturers, who have responded by offering lots of new minimalist models, are being swept up a little too easily themselves.
It's going to take me a while to sort this all out (and to learn more about the "barefoot debate"), but my present inclination is to think a lot of runners may have overreacted to the romance of the Born-to-Run cult. Philosophically, I like the idea of taking a cue from our ancient ancestors. (We need to do that in a lot of ways beyond just how we decide on footwear, as I discuss on the website http://www.willhumansendure.com/.) I think the science of the Running Man theory is sound. But civilization has subjected us to 10,000 years of cultural intervention and breeding that have separated us from our origins so drastically that it's unrealistic to think we can simply throw off our shoes and run free. Some can, but a lot of us can't. If you're starting to run at age 30 or 40 and have spent three or four decades letting your feet be carried around in rigid plastic or leather coffins on smooth floors or pavement, the muscles, tendons, and bones in your feet may retain very little of the strength and resilience our ancient ancestors had--or that today's Tarahumara still have. You may be better off doing what I did when I got those green-and-white Adidas. That was 52 years ago, and I'm still running strong. I have never bothered with shoes that cost $100 or more (McDougall is more on target in suggesting that buying one of the more expensive models can be a fool's errand), and for the past few years I've been happy with fairly basic Saucony or Asics models priced around $60 to $80, which have the same basic features those magical Adidas shoes had half a century ago. I hope the shoe companies keep making shoes like that for people like me. And if Chris McDougall would like to set up another "greatest race the world has never seen" with some of the over-70-year-old Tarahumara included, those guys can run in their sandals and I'll be there in my Sauconys. And I think I'll do pretty well.
Monday, May 2, 2011
John F. Kennedy and the Origin of Modern Ultrarunning
NOTE: This is a followup to my last blog, about President John F. Kennedy's worries that Americans were becoming too physically and mentally soft.
In the winter of 1962-63, during his ruminations about whether Americans were fit enough to meet the challenges of an increasingly dangerous age, President Kennedy came across an Executive Order that had been written half a century earlier by another president who valued physical vigor and had been similarly concerned. In 1908, Teddy Roosevelt had declared that all U.S. Marines should be able to prove their fitness by walking 50 miles in three days, doing the last half-mile by alternating 200 yards of double-time marching and 30 seconds of rest, then sprinting the final 200 yards. The records showed that some of TR's officers had done the distance in one day, and Kennedy wondered whether the Marines of 1963 were as fit as those of 1908. He sent a memo to the Marine commandant, General David Shoup, suggesting "Why don't you send this [Roosevelt's order] back to me as your own discovery? You might want to add a comment that today's Marine Corps officers are just as fit as those of 1980, and are willing to prove it. I, in turn, will ask Mr. Salinger [Pierre Salinger, the White House Press Secretary] for a report on the fitness of the White House staff."
That began the great "50-mile walk" phenomenon of 1963--a phenomenon that was regarded both then and later largely as a "craze". On February 5, the White House put out a press release about Roosevelt's order, noting that the president had suggested to General Shoup that he find out how well his Marines could do, compared with Teddy Roosevelt's Marines. A group of officers was called up to do the test. However, JFK's brother, Bobby Kennedy, decided he was going to do it too, and wasn't going to wait for the Marines. That Sunday, Bobby set out on a 50-mile hike with four of his aides, on the C&O Canal Towpath from the Washington, DC suburbs to Harpers Ferry, Virginia. The weather was freezing, the towpath was covered with slush, and one by one the aides all dropped out. As the last one quit at mile 35, Bobby Kennedy said to him, "You're lucky your brother isn't president of the United States." Kennedy reached 50 miles in 17 hours, 50 minutes.
Within days, thousands of civilians, likewise, had responded to the challenge intended for Marine officers. A 15-year-old, Paul Kiczek, did the distance and decades later revisited the experience in an Internet search of 1963 newspaper stories about the hikes. A New Jersey newspaper, The Daily Record, reported on February 15, 1963 that a 24-year-old policeman and ex-Marine, Francis wulff, had done the feat on the spur of the moment. "I read about some army officers shooting off their mouths about the Marines and I decided to give it a try," Wulff told the reporter. On February 16, the same paper reported that a group of eight teenagers from Boonton, New Jersey had set out in sub-freezing weather and three had gone the distance. One of them, 17-year-old Ken Middleton, remarkably finished the 50 miles in under 12 hours--which meant he had to have run a good part of the distance. On February 22, the paper reported that The Mansion House Tavern, in Boonton, had announced a competition, a "Fifty-Mile Endurance Walk," to take place on March 10, with a $25 Savings Bond for the winner and free draft beer for everyone who finished. Meanwhile, in Marin County, California, 400 high-school students set out to do the 50 miles, presumably even without the incentive of free beer, and 97 of them finished.
Across the country, the "fad" was met with quick scorn and skepticism from medical and health experts.
From the American Medical Association: "People can endanger themselves. We get distressed when people go out and strain themselves."
From the National Recreation Association: "The 50-mile hike verges on insanity."
From the Soviet Union's Olympic track coach: "So a man walks 50 miles in one day--what of it? Tomorrow he catches a taxicab again to go four blocks."
So, what was Kennedy thinking? Had he had second thoughts about his comment [in his Sports Illustrated article] that his goal was not to train our youth to be warriors like the ancient Spartans? One clue may be that unlike some of the more cocksure politicians who would succeed him, Kennedy had an abiding interest in military history and in the rises and falls of empires. He may have been more conscious than some of his generals that in the history of civilization, the capacity to conquer or destroy often turns out to be only the beginning of the story. Often, a decisive part of the story is a people's capacity to wait and endure. JFK was doubtless familiar with the history of the Arab revolt led by T.E. Lawrence (Lawrence of Arabia) in 1917, which dramatically demonstrated how consequential that capacity can be. The British, who were encouraging the revolt against the Ottoman Empire, wanted the Arabs to attack the Turks at their stronghold in Medina. But whereas the Turks had thousands of men, Lawrence had only a few hundred. The Turks had unassailable power, but the Arabs had something else--an ability to hit and run, striking repeatedly at the railroad that supplied the Turkish garrison. With all their heavy armor, the Turks couldn't effectively chase down their attackers, who travelled light and could fade into the desert, In his well-researched article in the May 11, 2009 New Yorker, "How David Beats Goliath," Malcolm Gladwell notes that Lawrence led his Bedouins over 600 miles in summer heat while the Turks stayed fixed in their garrison. He quotes Lawrence: "Our largest available resources were the tribesmen, quite unused to formal warfare, whose assets are movement, endurance, individual intelligence, knowledge of country...." In the end, the tribesmen killed or captured 1,200 Turks while losing only two men of their own. In this context, Gladwell quotes the 15th-century French general Maurice de Saxe, who famously said that the art of war is about legs, not arms. And, noted Gladwell, "Lawrence's troops were all legs."
However, I suspect Kennedy wasn't just thinking about the physical endurance of the Marines, but a broader set of concerns: the role of persistence as well as power, of patience as a reality check to impulsive urgency, and the long view as an essential factor in planning, especially in response to emergencies. I wonder if he may have sensed, even before its outlines were clear, that the world was headed toward a global emergency even more all-encompassing--and fateful--than that of the global war that had ended a few years earlier. Scientists had not yet foreseen the specter of catastrophic climate change. And the threats of ecological failure, resource wars, peak oil, and Malthusian outcomes were then only faint shadows on the horizon. Whatever JFK had in mind, he never got to fully explain in a thoughtful memoir,or even in policy discussions, as his life was suddenly cut off. But his call was taken to heart by more than just the Marines.
A few months after the 50-mile phenomenon began, President Kennedy was assassinated and the hiking party was over. The accepted view was that it all had been basically a fad, and that with the charismatic president gone, whatever real inspireation there had been in it had died with him. The decade would quickly turn to graver, and more turbulent, concerns. If anyone had sensed that personal fitness might be a precondition for societal wellbeing, that sense was numbed by the violence of the following years--from the assassination of Martin Luther King and Kennedy's brother Bobby, to the Vietnam War, the protests and riots, and the fast-spreading drug culture--a much quicker route to gratification in a country where ever-quicker routes were becoming the rule of the rising sprint culture-- than taking long hikes on winter days. Even as seemingly well-researched a history as Paul Kiczek's posting on the JFK hikes concluded that by the mid-1960s, the 50-mile fad had ended. "Interestingly, only one 50-mile event appears to remain active in the U.S.," Kiczek quite mistakenly wrote in 2009. Maybe he can be excused for not knowing, because such events are almost never seen or mentioned by sports shows or reporters, and rarely seen by the general public, as they usually take place on remote mountain or desert trails. But in fact, more than 500 ultramarathons were held in the United States that year. And the number has continued to grow since then.
The "one remaining" event Kiczek referred to was the appropriately named "JFK 50-mile," which was first held in 1963 and has been held every year since. The JFK 50 started as a hike, was soon changed to a "hike/run" and then to just the "JFK 50-mile run." It is the largest ultra in the U.S., and probably second only to Western States as the most competitive. This fall will be its 49th year, and I plan to be running.
In the winter of 1962-63, during his ruminations about whether Americans were fit enough to meet the challenges of an increasingly dangerous age, President Kennedy came across an Executive Order that had been written half a century earlier by another president who valued physical vigor and had been similarly concerned. In 1908, Teddy Roosevelt had declared that all U.S. Marines should be able to prove their fitness by walking 50 miles in three days, doing the last half-mile by alternating 200 yards of double-time marching and 30 seconds of rest, then sprinting the final 200 yards. The records showed that some of TR's officers had done the distance in one day, and Kennedy wondered whether the Marines of 1963 were as fit as those of 1908. He sent a memo to the Marine commandant, General David Shoup, suggesting "Why don't you send this [Roosevelt's order] back to me as your own discovery? You might want to add a comment that today's Marine Corps officers are just as fit as those of 1980, and are willing to prove it. I, in turn, will ask Mr. Salinger [Pierre Salinger, the White House Press Secretary] for a report on the fitness of the White House staff."
That began the great "50-mile walk" phenomenon of 1963--a phenomenon that was regarded both then and later largely as a "craze". On February 5, the White House put out a press release about Roosevelt's order, noting that the president had suggested to General Shoup that he find out how well his Marines could do, compared with Teddy Roosevelt's Marines. A group of officers was called up to do the test. However, JFK's brother, Bobby Kennedy, decided he was going to do it too, and wasn't going to wait for the Marines. That Sunday, Bobby set out on a 50-mile hike with four of his aides, on the C&O Canal Towpath from the Washington, DC suburbs to Harpers Ferry, Virginia. The weather was freezing, the towpath was covered with slush, and one by one the aides all dropped out. As the last one quit at mile 35, Bobby Kennedy said to him, "You're lucky your brother isn't president of the United States." Kennedy reached 50 miles in 17 hours, 50 minutes.
Within days, thousands of civilians, likewise, had responded to the challenge intended for Marine officers. A 15-year-old, Paul Kiczek, did the distance and decades later revisited the experience in an Internet search of 1963 newspaper stories about the hikes. A New Jersey newspaper, The Daily Record, reported on February 15, 1963 that a 24-year-old policeman and ex-Marine, Francis wulff, had done the feat on the spur of the moment. "I read about some army officers shooting off their mouths about the Marines and I decided to give it a try," Wulff told the reporter. On February 16, the same paper reported that a group of eight teenagers from Boonton, New Jersey had set out in sub-freezing weather and three had gone the distance. One of them, 17-year-old Ken Middleton, remarkably finished the 50 miles in under 12 hours--which meant he had to have run a good part of the distance. On February 22, the paper reported that The Mansion House Tavern, in Boonton, had announced a competition, a "Fifty-Mile Endurance Walk," to take place on March 10, with a $25 Savings Bond for the winner and free draft beer for everyone who finished. Meanwhile, in Marin County, California, 400 high-school students set out to do the 50 miles, presumably even without the incentive of free beer, and 97 of them finished.
Across the country, the "fad" was met with quick scorn and skepticism from medical and health experts.
From the American Medical Association: "People can endanger themselves. We get distressed when people go out and strain themselves."
From the National Recreation Association: "The 50-mile hike verges on insanity."
From the Soviet Union's Olympic track coach: "So a man walks 50 miles in one day--what of it? Tomorrow he catches a taxicab again to go four blocks."
So, what was Kennedy thinking? Had he had second thoughts about his comment [in his Sports Illustrated article] that his goal was not to train our youth to be warriors like the ancient Spartans? One clue may be that unlike some of the more cocksure politicians who would succeed him, Kennedy had an abiding interest in military history and in the rises and falls of empires. He may have been more conscious than some of his generals that in the history of civilization, the capacity to conquer or destroy often turns out to be only the beginning of the story. Often, a decisive part of the story is a people's capacity to wait and endure. JFK was doubtless familiar with the history of the Arab revolt led by T.E. Lawrence (Lawrence of Arabia) in 1917, which dramatically demonstrated how consequential that capacity can be. The British, who were encouraging the revolt against the Ottoman Empire, wanted the Arabs to attack the Turks at their stronghold in Medina. But whereas the Turks had thousands of men, Lawrence had only a few hundred. The Turks had unassailable power, but the Arabs had something else--an ability to hit and run, striking repeatedly at the railroad that supplied the Turkish garrison. With all their heavy armor, the Turks couldn't effectively chase down their attackers, who travelled light and could fade into the desert, In his well-researched article in the May 11, 2009 New Yorker, "How David Beats Goliath," Malcolm Gladwell notes that Lawrence led his Bedouins over 600 miles in summer heat while the Turks stayed fixed in their garrison. He quotes Lawrence: "Our largest available resources were the tribesmen, quite unused to formal warfare, whose assets are movement, endurance, individual intelligence, knowledge of country...." In the end, the tribesmen killed or captured 1,200 Turks while losing only two men of their own. In this context, Gladwell quotes the 15th-century French general Maurice de Saxe, who famously said that the art of war is about legs, not arms. And, noted Gladwell, "Lawrence's troops were all legs."
However, I suspect Kennedy wasn't just thinking about the physical endurance of the Marines, but a broader set of concerns: the role of persistence as well as power, of patience as a reality check to impulsive urgency, and the long view as an essential factor in planning, especially in response to emergencies. I wonder if he may have sensed, even before its outlines were clear, that the world was headed toward a global emergency even more all-encompassing--and fateful--than that of the global war that had ended a few years earlier. Scientists had not yet foreseen the specter of catastrophic climate change. And the threats of ecological failure, resource wars, peak oil, and Malthusian outcomes were then only faint shadows on the horizon. Whatever JFK had in mind, he never got to fully explain in a thoughtful memoir,or even in policy discussions, as his life was suddenly cut off. But his call was taken to heart by more than just the Marines.
A few months after the 50-mile phenomenon began, President Kennedy was assassinated and the hiking party was over. The accepted view was that it all had been basically a fad, and that with the charismatic president gone, whatever real inspireation there had been in it had died with him. The decade would quickly turn to graver, and more turbulent, concerns. If anyone had sensed that personal fitness might be a precondition for societal wellbeing, that sense was numbed by the violence of the following years--from the assassination of Martin Luther King and Kennedy's brother Bobby, to the Vietnam War, the protests and riots, and the fast-spreading drug culture--a much quicker route to gratification in a country where ever-quicker routes were becoming the rule of the rising sprint culture-- than taking long hikes on winter days. Even as seemingly well-researched a history as Paul Kiczek's posting on the JFK hikes concluded that by the mid-1960s, the 50-mile fad had ended. "Interestingly, only one 50-mile event appears to remain active in the U.S.," Kiczek quite mistakenly wrote in 2009. Maybe he can be excused for not knowing, because such events are almost never seen or mentioned by sports shows or reporters, and rarely seen by the general public, as they usually take place on remote mountain or desert trails. But in fact, more than 500 ultramarathons were held in the United States that year. And the number has continued to grow since then.
The "one remaining" event Kiczek referred to was the appropriately named "JFK 50-mile," which was first held in 1963 and has been held every year since. The JFK 50 started as a hike, was soon changed to a "hike/run" and then to just the "JFK 50-mile run." It is the largest ultra in the U.S., and probably second only to Western States as the most competitive. This fall will be its 49th year, and I plan to be running.
Friday, April 22, 2011
The "Soft American" Problem
This fall, I plan to run in the JFK 50-Mile again--I think for the 15th time, although I've lost count. (The photo at the top of this page is from last year's JFK, and I apologize for keeping it there so long--I'm a real dunce with photography and will replace it and add new images in the next couple of weeks, I hope!) At JFK, I'll be going into the age 70-79 division this year, and hope to show that some of us old guys can run too!
I noticed, on the JFK-50 website, that this will be the 49th annual running of that race, and it reminded me of the reason the race has that name. Fifty years ago last December, president-elect John F. Kennedy wrote an article for Sports Illustrated, "The Soft American," in which he began by observing that the ancient Greeks considered physical excellence to be "among man's greatest goals and among the prime foundations of a vigorous state." He wote:
This knowledge . . . that the physical well-being of the citizen is an
important foundation for the vigor and vitality of all the activities of
the nation, is as old as Western civilization itself. But it is a knowledge
which today, in America, we are in danger of forgetting.
Kennedy then reviewed a fairly shocking litany facts that had been the basis of his concern, and when I read it, just recently, I was struck by how prescient he had been about the "danger of forgetting." Among those now forgotten facts:
- Almost half of all young Americans examined by the Selective Service
in the late 1950s were rejected by the military as mentally, morally, or
physically unfit.
- In six tests of muscular strength and flexibility given to 4,264 American
children and 2,870 children in Austria, Italy, and Switzerland over
fifteen years of research, 57% of the American children failed one or
more of the tests while only 9 percent of the European children failed.
- In physical fitness tests given to freshmen at Yale University, there
had been a steady decline in the number who passed--from 51% in
1951 to 43% in 1956 to just 38% in 1960.
In calling for greater attention to the fitness of the country's kids, Kennedy also emphasized that "we do not, like the ancient Spartans, wish to train the bodies of our youth to make them more effective warriors." Rather, he was suggesting something both more radical and, ultimately, far more important:
Physical fitness is as vital to the activities of peace as to those of
war.... It is the basis of dynamic and creative intellectual activity. The
relationship between the soundness of the body and the activities of
the mind is subtle and complex. Much of it is not yet understood.
But we do know what the Greeks knew: that intelligence and skill
can only function at the peak of their capacity when the body is healthy
and strong; that hardy spirits and tough minds usually inhabit sound
bodies. . . . If we fail to encourage physical development and prowess,
we will undermine our capacity for thought, for work, and for the use
of those skills vital to an expanding and complex America.
After the Bay of Pigs fiasco in Cuba, soon after he took office, Kennedy might well have wondered if the CIA and military had done their planning in a stupor. (Half a century later, as we drift into the 10th or 11th year of Orwellian war in Afghanistan, have we learned anything at all?) And then, with the escalating development of hydrogen bombs hundreds of times the power of the bomb that destroyed Hiroshima, something far more ominous loomed--the nuclear arms race punctuated by the Cuban missile crisis, which came terrifyingly close to raining Armageddon on our country.
Kennedy's "New Frontier" was aimed at breaking America out of its mid-century complacency. As a visionary leader, he would be remembered most for his call to launch the Apollo moon-flight program, which would amazingly land a man on the moon within a decade. But in retrospect, it was the call he made for a tougher, more physically and mentally fit citizenry that may ultimately have been the more important call.
A couple of years after writing his "Soft American" article, president Kennedy followed up with another initiative that captured the imaginations of thousands of Americans and resulted in the launch of the great 50-mile trail race that now bears his name.
Next post: JFK and the rise of ultrarunning in 20th-century America
I noticed, on the JFK-50 website, that this will be the 49th annual running of that race, and it reminded me of the reason the race has that name. Fifty years ago last December, president-elect John F. Kennedy wrote an article for Sports Illustrated, "The Soft American," in which he began by observing that the ancient Greeks considered physical excellence to be "among man's greatest goals and among the prime foundations of a vigorous state." He wote:
This knowledge . . . that the physical well-being of the citizen is an
important foundation for the vigor and vitality of all the activities of
the nation, is as old as Western civilization itself. But it is a knowledge
which today, in America, we are in danger of forgetting.
Kennedy then reviewed a fairly shocking litany facts that had been the basis of his concern, and when I read it, just recently, I was struck by how prescient he had been about the "danger of forgetting." Among those now forgotten facts:
- Almost half of all young Americans examined by the Selective Service
in the late 1950s were rejected by the military as mentally, morally, or
physically unfit.
- In six tests of muscular strength and flexibility given to 4,264 American
children and 2,870 children in Austria, Italy, and Switzerland over
fifteen years of research, 57% of the American children failed one or
more of the tests while only 9 percent of the European children failed.
- In physical fitness tests given to freshmen at Yale University, there
had been a steady decline in the number who passed--from 51% in
1951 to 43% in 1956 to just 38% in 1960.
In calling for greater attention to the fitness of the country's kids, Kennedy also emphasized that "we do not, like the ancient Spartans, wish to train the bodies of our youth to make them more effective warriors." Rather, he was suggesting something both more radical and, ultimately, far more important:
Physical fitness is as vital to the activities of peace as to those of
war.... It is the basis of dynamic and creative intellectual activity. The
relationship between the soundness of the body and the activities of
the mind is subtle and complex. Much of it is not yet understood.
But we do know what the Greeks knew: that intelligence and skill
can only function at the peak of their capacity when the body is healthy
and strong; that hardy spirits and tough minds usually inhabit sound
bodies. . . . If we fail to encourage physical development and prowess,
we will undermine our capacity for thought, for work, and for the use
of those skills vital to an expanding and complex America.
After the Bay of Pigs fiasco in Cuba, soon after he took office, Kennedy might well have wondered if the CIA and military had done their planning in a stupor. (Half a century later, as we drift into the 10th or 11th year of Orwellian war in Afghanistan, have we learned anything at all?) And then, with the escalating development of hydrogen bombs hundreds of times the power of the bomb that destroyed Hiroshima, something far more ominous loomed--the nuclear arms race punctuated by the Cuban missile crisis, which came terrifyingly close to raining Armageddon on our country.
Kennedy's "New Frontier" was aimed at breaking America out of its mid-century complacency. As a visionary leader, he would be remembered most for his call to launch the Apollo moon-flight program, which would amazingly land a man on the moon within a decade. But in retrospect, it was the call he made for a tougher, more physically and mentally fit citizenry that may ultimately have been the more important call.
A couple of years after writing his "Soft American" article, president Kennedy followed up with another initiative that captured the imaginations of thousands of Americans and resulted in the launch of the great 50-mile trail race that now bears his name.
Next post: JFK and the rise of ultrarunning in 20th-century America
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)